Car Accident? Not All Kinds Will Make Your Insurance Go Up
Editorial Note: We earn a commission from partner links on Forbes Advisor. Commissions do not affect our editors’ opinions or evaluations.
This might come as a surprise, but not everyone is a great driver. Almost a third of all collisions are rear-end collisions, according to the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration. These types of accidents often take place when someone crashes into a stopped car at a red light or stop sign.
We also tend to run into things. More than 20% of collisions are with stationary objects such as poles, shrubbery or a parked car. And we crash into parked cars (358,000) way more often than poles and posts (208,000).
But not all accidents will make your insurance rates go up.
What Is a “Chargeable” Accident?
A chargeable accident is one that can lead to an auto insurance rate increase. This generally means an accident where you were more than 50% at fault and that caused:
- Damage to property, like another car or someone’s fence.
- Bodily injury or death.
Some states might define a chargeable accident in terms of a dollar amount. For example, in Minnesota, a chargeable accident is defined as an accident for which the car insurance company paid more than $500 under bodily injury liability, collision or property damage coverage, with some exceptions.
Some states, such as Massachusetts, consider a chargeable accident one that involves a claim payment of more than $1,000 for property damage liability, collision or bodily injury coverage (for accidents where the operator is more than 50% at fault and driving a private passenger vehicle).
Not All Accidents Make Your Insurance Rates Go Up
Not all car accidents are “chargeable.” Here are typical examples of non-chargeable accidents:
- Your car was legally parked when it was damaged.
- Your car was struck in the rear by another vehicle and you (or the driver of your car) were not convicted of a moving traffic violation in relation to the accident.
- Your car was struck in a hit-and-run accident. (You may be required to report the accident to the police within 24 hours after discovering the damage, depending on the state and insurance policy.)
- The driver of another car was convicted of a moving traffic violation associated with the accident, but you were not convicted of a moving traffic violation.
- The accident was caused by a collision with an animal or fowl.
- The damage was caused by falling objects or flying gravel or missile-like objects.
- The accident happened when you were responding to an emergency and you are a volunteer or paid member of the fire department, first aid squad or law enforcement agency.
- Your car insurance company was able to recover 80% or more of your collision insurance claim through subrogation (typically, this means they were able to collect from the other driver’s car insurance company).
- You were reimbursed by the person who caused the damage.
- There is a court judgment for the accident against the person who caused the damage.
- Accidents in which claim payments are made under the personal injury protection (PIP) coverage and no payments are made under liability or collision insurance.
How To Prove You’re Not at Fault
An auto insurance company might require proof from you that an accident was not your fault and therefore not chargeable. Satisfactory proof can vary among companies but often includes:
- A police report that says who was at fault.
- A statement from the other driver’s insurance company accepting fault.
- A legal document showing that you were reimbursed for damage.
- A driver’s written statement, under penalty of perjury, attesting to their fault.
What’s an Auto Insurance Surcharge?
A surcharge is the insurance increase you can get after a chargeable accident. You’ll find out whether you’re getting a surcharge at renewal time. An insurer can’t start surcharging you in the middle of the policy period.
Car accidents are not the only problems that can result in a surcharge. You can also get surcharges for moving violations.
How Long Does a Surcharge Affect My Car Insurance Rates?
The length of a surcharge for a car accident depends on your state and insurance company, but will typically last three to five years. For example, states such as New Jersey, New York and Texas only allow insurance companies to surcharge you for accidents for the past three years.
Depending on your state and insurance company, a surcharge could be applied to your insurance policy, but the added cost could decrease each year you drive without an accident (or any other surchargeable events). For example, if you live in a state that looks only at the past three years of your driving record, the surcharge increase may be non-existent after three years of safe driving.
What’s the Difference Between a Chargeable Accident and a Chargeable Incident?
A chargeable incident typically refers to a moving violation, such as a speeding ticket, leaving the scene of an accident or driving under the influence. Like an accident, a chargeable incident typically affects your car insurance rates for three to five years, depending on your state.
What Else Causes an Insurance Increase?
Rate increases can vary by insurance company and state laws, but here are some common factors insurance companies consider:
- Severity of the accident. The overall severity of an accident and cost of a claim can impact rates. A minor fender bender typically doesn’t have the same impact as a major accident.
- Your driving history. Car insurance companies like safe drivers. If you’ve gone several years with no accidents or moving violations, your insurance company may not raise your rates for a minor accident.
- Policy details. Your car insurance policy might include accident forgiveness, which generally means your insurer won’t raise your rates after an accident.
How Does Accident Forgiveness Work?
If your policy includes accident forgiveness and you cause a car accident, your insurer will “forgive” the accident and won’t increase your rates. You’ll typically have to pay extra for accident forgiveness, and some insurance companies such as Geico offer it as a free perk to certain customers.
Related: Should you settle a car accident privately?
Here are some things to know about accident forgiveness:
- Not all car insurance companies offer accident forgiveness. And some states don’t allow it, such as California.
- Accident forgiveness is limited. Accident forgiveness usually only applies to one accident per policy, not one accident per driver on the policy. And you might only be able to use it once within a certain timeframe. For example, Farmers Insurance will forgive one at-fault accident for every three years you drive without an accident.
- The accident stays on your driving record, even if it’s “forgiven”. Even if your car insurance company forgives your accident, it will still be on your motor vehicle record. Other insurance companies can see your driving record, which could affect your rates if you decide to switch insurance companies.
How Does My Insurance Company Find Out About Car Accidents?
Car insurance companies typically look at your motor vehicle record (MVR) when you apply for a new policy and every year around renewal time. Your MVR will include accidents that were reported to the state. For example, if police responded to the scene of an accident and filed a report, it will be included in the MVR.
In some states, like New York, you are required by law to file an accident report to the DMV for any car accident with damage over $1,000 or if anyone sustains an injury.
Your MVR might also include:
- Traffic citation convictions.
- Court convictions.
- License suspension and revocation actions.
- License restoration dates.
- Insurance status.
- Ignition interlock requirements.
You can order a copy of your MVR from your state’s department of motor vehicles.
Insurance companies typically won’t rely solely on your MVR. Many insurance companies subscribe to databases that show your past claims. Insurance companies will report claims for which they:
- Paid out money.
- Set up a file for a possible claim (such as after you call your insurance agent to ask about damage).
- Formally deny a claim.
Here are some databases insurance companies commonly use.
- A-Plus Auto Loss History Reports. This report collects previously filed insurance claims, including bodily injury, comprehensive and collision, personal injury protection and property damage claims. You can request one free report every 12 months.
- CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange). This report generally has up to seven years of auto claims history, including dates of damage, type of claim and the amount the company paid. You can request your personal report.
Compare Rates and Save on Your Auto Loan
Get up to 4 loan offers in minutes at myAutoloan.com.
Car Accidents and Insurance Rates FAQ
Will my rates go up if I cause an accident?
Your car insurance rates will likely go up if you cause an accident. For example, if you rear-end another car at a stop light, the other driver could make a claim for car damage and injuries against your car liability insurance. At your next renewal time you could see a rate increase.
Will my car insurance rates go up if my car was involved in a hit and run?
Generally, hit-and-run car accidents will not cause your car insurance rates to go up. You can file a claim for car repairs under the collision insurance portion of your policy. For hit-and-run accidents, your insurer may require you to report the accident within 24 hours of discovering the damage.
Will accident forgiveness coverage save me from a rate increase?
If you cause a car accident and you have accident forgiveness coverage, you won’t see a rate increase. But there’s a catch. The accident will stay on your driving record even if your insurance company “forgives” you. That means the accident could impact your future rates if you decide to switch insurance companies.